Nutrition & DietResearch PaperPaywall

Low-carb, low-fat or balanced diet: all three trimmed visceral fat equally in six months

In a 6-month randomized trial of overweight adults, low-carb, low-fat and balanced diets shrank visceral fat and improved markers alike. Macronutrient mix did not matter.

Wednesday, November 18, 2026 0 views
Published in Eur J Clin Nutr
A dietitian measuring a seated overweight adult's abdomen with an ultrasound probe in a bright clinic room

Summary

Belly fat, especially the visceral fat packed around organs, is closely linked to heart and metabolic disease. Researchers in Brazil asked whether the way you cut calories matters. They randomized overweight adults to one of three individualized diets: balanced macronutrients, lower carbohydrate, or lower fat. A control group received only general counseling. After six months, body weight and visceral fat (measured by ultrasound) dropped over time, with average weight loss of about 3%. Total cholesterol, glucose, HbA1c and blood pressure also improved over time. The key result is a null: no meaningful differences in the trajectories between diet types. The abstract does not report effect sizes or how the control group compared. For readers, the finding suggests that choosing a diet you can stick with may matter more than the carb-to-fat ratio, at least for modest weight loss over six months.

Detailed Summary

Visceral fat, the fat stored deep in the abdomen around organs, is a stronger driver of cardiometabolic risk than total body weight, and it rises with age. People optimizing healthspan often debate which diet best reduces it, and no consensus exists.

This randomized clinical trial from Brazil, with a senior author collaboration in Spain, tested three individualized diets in overweight adults: caloric restriction with balanced macronutrients (BALANCED), carbohydrate reduction (LOWCARB), and fat reduction (LOWFAT). A control group (CONTROL) received qualitative, group-based counseling. Participants were followed for six months, with assessments at baseline, three and six months. Visceral and subcutaneous adipose tissue were measured by ultrasound, alongside body weight, blood biochemistry and blood pressure. Physical activity was not changed.

Body weight and visceral fat fell significantly over time, with average weight loss around 3%. Total cholesterol, glucose, HbA1c and blood pressure also changed significantly over time. Critically, there were no significant time-by-group interactions for any of these outcomes, meaning the trajectories were comparable across groups. The authors found no evidence that macronutrient composition changed the effect on visceral fat or cardiometabolic markers.

This is a clear null on the specific question of whether carb or fat restriction beats a balanced approach. It does not show that diet is ineffective: improvements occurred over time. The mechanism implied is that energy deficit and modest weight loss, rather than macronutrient ratio, drive visceral fat reduction in this setting. Because the abstract reports time effects across groups, including the control group, it is unclear how much the intervention itself added.

Caveats: this summary is based on the abstract only, so sample size, dropout, effect sizes, adherence and control group results are unknown. Ultrasound is a less precise measure of visceral fat than MRI or CT. Six months is short, weight loss was modest, and the results are surrogate markers, not cardiovascular events or lifespan.

Key Findings

  • Body weight and ultrasound-measured visceral fat fell significantly over six months, with average weight loss around 3%.
  • Total cholesterol, glucose, HbA1c and blood pressure also changed significantly over time.
  • No significant time-by-group interactions: balanced, low-carb and low-fat diets produced comparable trajectories (a null on macronutrient effect).
  • Results are surrogate markers over six months; no cardiovascular events or lifespan outcomes were assessed.

Methodology

Randomized clinical trial in overweight adults with four arms: three individualized calorie-restricted diets (BALANCED, LOWCARB, LOWFAT) and a counseling-only control. Assessments at baseline, 3 and 6 months, with visceral and subcutaneous fat by ultrasound, plus weight, biochemistry and blood pressure, analyzed as time-by-group interactions. Physical activity was not altered.

Study Limitations

Summary is based on the abstract only, so sample size, attrition, effect sizes, adherence and control-group comparisons are not available. Ultrasound is less precise for visceral fat than MRI or CT, and a null interaction in a possibly modest sample may reflect limited power. Six months and surrogate endpoints cannot speak to long-term outcomes.

Enjoyed this summary?

Get the latest longevity research delivered to your inbox every week.

Enter your email to subscribe: